Unpacking Modular UPS: Is It Truly Modular?

Unpacking Modular UPS: Is It Truly Modular?

Are you in the driver's seat of purchasing or maintaining your IT infrastructure? If so, the reliability of your critical IT equipment is probably at the top of your concerns. Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) play a vital role in safeguarding your operations, and modular UPS systems are often touted as the solution to seamless power protection.

Not every modular UPS system lives up to its 'modular' claim. Are you certain that your UPS solution is as flexible and reliable as it needs to be? To make an informed decision and guarantee uninterrupted power for your critical IT equipment, it's vital to grasp the critical distinctions between genuinely modular systems and those that fall short. Let's delve into the question: Is a modular UPS truly as modular as it claims to be?

What is a True Modular UPS?

A modular UPS system is designed to be scalable and adaptable to meet changing power demands. It promises to be more reliable because it allows for easy expansion, redundancy, and maintenance without downtime. But not all modular UPS systems are created equal.

So, what should you look for when purchasing a modular UPS? The key lies in understanding whether it's genuinely "modular." Here are some questions to ask:

  1. Is It Truly Modular N+(X)?

 A true modular UPS should offer N+(X) redundancy to ensure high availability and fault-tolerant environments, meaning that if one component fails, others can take over seamlessly. Ask your UPS provider if their system adheres to this standard.

  1. How Can You Tell Them Apart?

One way to differentiate between a true modular UPS and a less modular system is by looking at how hot-swappable the components are. In a true modular UPS, you can replace or add modules while the system is running, minimising downtime. If it requires a shutdown for any modifications, it might not be as modular as you'd like. Ask the question, What are the single points of failure? You might be surprised. Unlocking the Advantages of True Modular UPS

Let's put it plainly. A true modular UPS:

  • Offers hot-swappable modules: You can replace or add modules without shutting down the system.
  • Provides N+1 redundancy: It ensures your operations stay online even if a module fails.
  • Scales easily: You can expand your power capacity effortlessly as your needs grow.
  • Is flexible: You can customise it to suit your specific requirements.

But there's another critical advantage to highlight – a true modular UPS eliminates single points of failure. Unlike some less modular systems, where a single failure can jeopardise your entire operation, a true modular UPS ensures uninterrupted power even in the face of unexpected challenges.


What are the Single Points of Failure?

A typical UPS comprises the following core components:

  1. Central Static Switch
  2. Central Graphic Display
  3. Power Modules
  4. Central Logic Control
  5. Centralised Batteries


A typical Standalone UPS Architecture comprises these 5 Single points of failure. To grade a truly modular UPS, we need to eliminate as many of these single points of failure as possible. Depending upon the application, you grade the UPS that best fits your needs, but understanding these single points of failure may help understand the difference in Modular UPS options on the market today.

Standalone Architecture

A typical Modular UPS Architecture provides redundancy in the power modules. These power modules enable the scalability of the UPS and redundancy in the event a power module fails. Power modules in a UPS typically refer to the component responsible for converting the incoming AC Power to DC Power for battery charging and then back to AC Power for the output.

The chances of a power module failure in a Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) can vary depending upon factors including the quality of the UPS, its design, the operating conditions, and the maintenance practices. While generally less common than battery failures, power modules can and do fail, so if uptime is critical, this single point of failure is an important part of a Modular UPS Architecture.

In light of this standard Modular UPS Architecture, the removal of Power Modules as a single point of failure makes this architecture 4 single points of failure.

Typical Modular Architecture

When selecting a UPS system with minimal single points of failure, it's essential to consider factors such as the criticality of the load, desired uptime, budget, and specific requirements of your application.

A true 100% Modular Architecture termed DARA (Distributed Active Redundant Architecture) removes all single points of failure by having each component fully independent of the other. It features a distributed approach to redundancy and fault tolerance, where multiple independent power modules and control modules are interconnected to form a highly resilient system. Each power module operates independently, delivering power to the load, while the control modules coordinate and monitor the system's operation.

DARA Modular Architecture

Let's take a deeper look at these benefits.

The benefits of a truly modular UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) system are significant, especially for businesses and organisations that rely on critical IT infrastructure. Here are 8 key advantages:

  1. Scalability

True modular UPS systems are designed to be easily expandable. You can increase your power capacity as your needs grow, without the need for a complete system overhaul. This scalability is crucial for businesses that anticipate growth or have fluctuating power demands.

  1. Reliability

 One of the primary benefits of a modular UPS is N+1 redundancy. If one module fails, the others can seamlessly take over the load, ensuring uninterrupted power to your critical equipment. This redundancy minimises the risk of downtime and data loss.

  1. Flexibility

True modular UPS systems are highly adaptable. You can customise them to meet your specific requirements, whether it's for a small server room or a large datacentre. This flexibility allows you to tailor your power protection solution to your unique needs.

  1. Ease of Maintenance

 Modular UPS systems are designed for ease of maintenance. Hot-swappable modules mean you can replace or add components without shutting down the entire system. This reduces downtime during maintenance activities and ensures continuous operation.

  1. Cost-Efficiency

While the initial investment in a modular UPS may be higher than traditional systems, it can lead to cost savings over time. Scalability means you only invest in the capacity you need, and the reliability reduces the financial impact of unexpected downtime.

  1. Energy Efficiency

Many true modular UPS systems are designed with energy efficiency in mind. They can operate at higher efficiency levels, which can result in lower energy consumption and reduced operational costs.

  1. Future-Proofing

 Investing in a truly modular UPS system is a form of future-proofing your IT infrastructure. As your needs change and technology evolves, a modular system can adapt and grow with your organisation, reducing the need for frequent upgrades.

  1. Peace of Mind

Knowing that your critical IT equipment is protected by a reliable and scalable UPS system provides peace of mind. It allows you to focus on your core business operations without worrying about power interruptions.

These benefits make it an ideal choice for businesses and organisations that rely on uninterrupted power for their critical IT operations.

Comparing True Modular vs. Semi-Modular UPS

Let's simplify things even further with a table to highlight the differences between a true modular UPS and a semi-modular UPS system.

FEATURE TRUE MODULAR UPS SEMI-MODULAR UPS
Redundancy High Level, no single point of failure Medium, some single points of failure
Scalability Granular, expandable Easy expandable
Maintenance Simplified maintenance May require some shutdown
Fault Tolerance High tolerance Failure in central module can affect entire module
Cost Higher upfront investment Lower cost 
Implementation Complexity Higher complexity Easier to implement
 Flexibility Better flexible placement of UPS Flexible scalability and expansion

Making Informed Choices for Your UPS

Now that you have a clear understanding of what makes a UPS system truly modular, it's time to assess your current setup. Are you getting the flexibility, scalability, and reliability you need? If not, it might be time to rethink your UPS strategy.

Not all modular UPS systems are created equal. It's crucial to understand the key differences between true modular and less modular systems to make an informed decision. By doing so, you can ensure that your critical IT equipment remains powered and protected, even in the face of unexpected challenges.

Ultimately, the choice between DARA Architecture and a standard modular UPS depends on the specific requirements of the application, the desired level of redundancy and fault tolerance, scalability needs, budget considerations, and the expertise available for system design and maintenance. It's important to evaluate these factors and consult with UPS experts or manufacturers to determine the most suitable solution for a particular application.

At Treske, we specialise in providing IT resilience solutions that meet the demands of IT managers and facilities managers across various industries in Australia. Speak to us today for a health check of your UPS system and discover how we can help you achieve true modularity.

 

Explore Our Modular UPS Product Range

Take a look at our comprehensive range of Modular UPS solutions to ensure the uninterrupted power and protection your IT infrastructure deserves.

 

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.